Why a 17-Year WordPress Agency Built Its Own CMS With Claude
By Matt Cullerton, founder of Mavric and Apso
TJ Robertson's agency has built WordPress websites for 17 years, and about half of its clients still run on it. In a TikTok from @tjrobertson52 he says, "I don't think we'll ever build another WordPress website again," because his team used Claude to build its own CMS in a weekend. The direction is credible, but the video shows none of the new CMS, so the weekend-build claim is untested.
Why does he say WordPress is not AI native?
Robertson agrees that you can connect AI to WordPress and that MCP servers for WordPress exist. His point is that a connection is different from a platform an agent can run end to end. His test is practical. Claude can build you an HTML website directly, but it cannot build you a WordPress website the same way. When you connect AI to WordPress, he says, "it fights you every step of the way."
WordPress has AI plugins and integrations. Its architecture (PHP templates, a database-bound page builder layer and a plugin ecosystem) predates AI agents and was not designed for them to operate. An AI-native stack is one an agent can read, modify and deploy end to end.
What alternatives did the agency try first?
The agency spent six months evaluating AI-native CMS options. Robertson names two:
- EmDash, the open-source, Astro-based CMS that Cloudflare launched in 2026 as a WordPress successor, with a built-in MCP server.
- Payload, the TypeScript-based headless CMS.
Neither one stuck. During the same period the agency's web dev lead, Hana, built her own CMS. Robertson cites that as a sign the team expected to leave WordPress before it had a replacement.
What changed the plan, he says, was Claude Fable, Anthropic's coding-focused model. "Fable is so good at software engineering, we've been able to build a ton of software." One of those projects became the agency's production CMS.
What is in the custom CMS?
Robertson says Hana built the agency's ideal CMS in a weekend using Claude Fable. He lists these features:
- Every WordPress feature the team cared about, including a drag-and-drop page builder
- Pages built as HTML with Next.js rather than PHP templates
- Direct integration with each client's knowledge base on GitHub
- Easy migration of existing websites into the system
- Hosting on Vercel, set up so clients own their website while the agency keeps access
On lock-in, he argues that the output is plain HTML and JavaScript files, so moving to another CMS later would be easy. A small team of AI-native developers now maintains the system, and over the next six months he expects to recommend that many existing clients switch.
Is a weekend-built CMS a real WordPress replacement?
Parts of the argument hold up. Cloudflare launching EmDash as an explicit WordPress successor shows a large infrastructure company betting the same way. Robertson also limits his own claim: he will not move e-commerce clients yet, which concedes that WooCommerce-level stores are hard to replace with a weekend build.
Other parts are unproven:
- The weekend is the first build. A CMS also needs auth, permissions, backups, security patching and editor training. WordPress spreads that cost across millions of users. One agency carries it alone.
- Bus factor. A CMS maintained by one agency is a risk for every client on it, even if the output files are portable.
- No product on screen. The video is a walking selfie with captions. It has no screen recording or demo, so there is no way to judge whether the drag-and-drop builder matches what WordPress clients are used to.
Bottom line
Robertson's case is that AI coding now makes a purpose-built CMS cheaper to maintain than a 20-year-old platform that resists AI tooling. His agency evaluated EmDash and Payload, then built a Next.js CMS on Vercel with Claude Fable. The idea is plausible for brochure sites, he excludes e-commerce for now, and the video offers no footage of the CMS working.
Sources
- EmDash CMS - Cloudflare's open-source, Astro-based AI-native CMS
- EmDash on GitHub - MIT-licensed source code
- Cloudflare debuts EmDash (SiliconANGLE) - launch coverage, April 2026
- Payload - the TypeScript headless CMS the agency evaluated
- Next.js - the framework the custom CMS builds pages with
- Vercel - where the client sites are hosted
- Claude - Anthropic's AI assistant, credited with the build
Published July 17, 2026. Based on a TikTok by @tjrobertson52. Full video notes (markdown)