Whatnot CPO Tom Verrilli: Why He Regrets Product Management Exists
By Matt Cullerton, founder of Mavric and Apso
Whatnot's chief product officer, Tom Verrilli, says the company's product team was built on the premise that "we regret that product management exists." A TikTok clip of the interview headlines it as "PRODUCT MANAGEMENT SHOULDN'T EXIST," which is stronger than what he said. Whatnot still employs product managers, and the history he cites holds for tech but not for the discipline as a whole.
The clip, posted by @tech.podcast0, names neither speaker. It is an 85-second excerpt from a Lenny's Podcast episode.
Where does the quote come from?
The source is the Lenny's Podcast episode "This CPO regrets that product management exists | Tom Verrilli (CPO of Whatnot)," published August 2, 2026, with a runtime of 1 hour 25 minutes. The host reading the quote is Lenny Rachitsky.
Verrilli's Shoptalk speaker bio says he was previously chief product officer at Twitch, where he "led Product, Engineering, and Applied Science across all consumer products," and held senior product roles at Twitter before that. He is originally from Sydney, Australia.
The TikTok went up on September 24, 2026, 53 days after the episode. It carries no date, no company figures and no link back to the episode.
What did Tom Verrilli actually say?
Rachitsky reads back something Verrilli wrote: "since its earliest inception, the WhatNot product team was built on a somewhat simple premise, we regret that product management exists."
The clip's on-screen captions never show the words "we regret that." A viewer reading only the text sees "PRODUCT MANAGEMENT EXISTS" under a header that says "PRODUCT MANAGEMENT SHOULDN'T EXIST." Regretting that a role exists is different from saying it should not exist.
Verrilli explains the premise through history. "I always try and start with like history in order to understand kind of things," he says. "If you go all the way back, like product management didn't exist, right?" His argument is that product management meant handing the thinking about how to build something to a separate person. He calls it "a more modern function than it is a like pure necessity."
Does Whatnot have product managers?
It does. The premise works as a high hiring bar, not a ban. The episode description says Whatnot received 31,832 applications for product manager roles.
When did product management start?
Verrilli's claim that product management "didn't exist" if you go back far enough holds for software. It does not hold for the discipline.
The commonly cited origin is a memo from Procter & Gamble. On May 13, 1931, a 26-year-old employee named Neil McElroy wrote a three-page memo proposing "Brand Men" who would own a product end to end. He got permission to hire two people.
Ken Norton, who wrote an essay for the memo's ninetieth anniversary, adds a caveat: "I'm not convinced McElroy's memo is the exact point when product management was birthed, any more than Homo erectus was the spawning point of humanity. It was more evolutionary than that."
So the idea that a specialist role owning product decisions is a modern invention is defensible for software product management. The idea that nobody owned a product before tech companies is not.
How big is Whatnot?
The episode description calls Whatnot "the fastest-growing U.S. marketplace business in history, with over $8 billion in GMV." That is the company's and the podcast's description, and the $8 billion is the full-year 2025 figure.
Five days after the episode published, on August 7, 2026, Whatnot announced a $545 million Series G at a $20 billion valuation, according to Tubefilter. ICONIQ, Lightspeed and Avra led the round, with Andreessen Horowitz, Greycroft and Y Combinator also participating. Whatnot reported 650,000 new users per week.
By the time the TikTok posted, the $8 billion figure described a year Whatnot had already moved past.
What the clip leaves out
The clip is about 1.7 percent of the full episode. It has a few other gaps:
- Neither speaker is named in the audio or on screen.
- The header text, "PRODUCT MANAGEMENT SHOULDN'T EXIST," is the editor's wording, not Verrilli's.
- The clip includes Verrilli's history argument but not the context of how Whatnot's product team works day to day.
The full episode transcript on Lenny's Newsletter is behind a paid subscription.
Bottom line
Verrilli's line is that Whatnot "regret[s] that product management exists," not that the role should be abolished, and Whatnot still hires product managers from a large applicant pool. His point that product management is a modern function holds for tech. The discipline itself is usually traced to a 1931 Procter & Gamble memo. Whatnot raised $545 million at a $20 billion valuation days after the episode aired.
Sources
- This CPO regrets that product management exists, Lenny's Newsletter - the episode and its description
- Apple Podcasts episode listing - runtime, release date and the 31,832 applications figure
- Whatnot CPO Tom Verrilli write-up, BigGo Finance - secondary write-up of the episode
- Tom Verrilli speaker bio, Shoptalk - his roles at Whatnot, Twitch and Twitter
- Whatnot achieves $20 billion valuation, Tubefilter - Series G details
- Product Management Was Born in 1931 (Maybe, Sort Of) - the McElroy memo
Published September 24, 2026. Based on a TikTok by @tech.podcast0. Full video notes (markdown)