Tom Verrilli on Product Management: What Whatnot's CPO Really Said
By Matt Cullerton, founder of Mavric and Apso
In a clip from Lenny's Podcast, Whatnot Chief Product Officer Tom Verrilli argues that product management is "a trade, not a qualification," and that teams work best when engineers and designers have enough context to make product decisions themselves. A TikTok from @tech.podcast0 reposts the clip with no attribution and a caption reading "PMS ARE A MUSCLE, NOT A JOB." That caption conflicts with what he says in the same 73 seconds: "product management plays a really important role."
Who is Tom Verrilli?
The TikTok never names him. The clip comes from the Lenny's Podcast episode "This CPO regrets that product management exists | Tom Verrilli (CPO of Whatnot)," published on 2 August 2026 and running about 85 minutes.
Shoptalk's speaker page lists him as Chief Product Officer at Whatnot and previously CPO at Twitch, originally from Sydney and based in San Francisco. Twitch's blog confirms the earlier role in an open letter from 25 January 2023 that begins "My name is Tom Verrilli, and I'm the Chief Product Officer here at Twitch." Airtree's advisor page traces his path from ZipDial, acquired by Twitter in January 2015, to product internationalisation at Twitter and then Twitch.
What did Tom Verrilli say about product managers?
He opens with how Whatnot thinks about it: "it would actually be way better if engineering and design had the context that they needed to just make great decisions there."
His case for PM as a specialist role is narrow: "The only argument as far as I'm aware for why you would want product management to be a specialist function is really it's a trade, not a qualification." He says that "wherever possible, it's kind of optimal to not have a product manager."
He then sets limits on that: "And so I think product management plays a really important role. And I think you can deploy product management ... on particular things that need to go really well."
Is product management "a muscle, not a job"?
That is the TikTok's caption, not his argument. He says PM is a craft built through practice, not a credential, and that it should be deployed on the specific projects that need to go really well. He is not saying the job should not exist. He holds it.
Whatnot still has a PM organisation. The episode's chapters include "How Whatnot structures its PM org" at 15:20 and "What 31,832 PM applications revealed about the function" at 17:28, and Whatnot still hires product managers. The TikTok's written title, "Great PMs aren't a qualification, they're a trade built through reps," is closer to what he says.
Why would PMs weaken engineering and design?
His core claim is about practice: "the more you abstract your engineers and your designers from doing the same thing, their muscle gets underdeveloped." If PMs make every product call, engineers and designers stop building that judgment.
He offers no data for this. The analogy he uses is a personal trainer, not a study. Treat it as a senior operator's view of how his own organisation behaves.
Does Whatnot's growth prove the model works?
Whatnot is growing fast. Tubefilter reported on 7 August 2026 that it raised a $545 million Series G at a $20 billion valuation, led by ICONIQ, Lightspeed and Avra. The same report cites $8 billion in live GMV for 2025 and roughly 650,000 new users per week. Lenny's episode page calls Whatnot "the fastest-growing U.S. marketplace business in history, with over $8 billion in GMV."
These figures are company-reported and not independently audited. None of them isolates the PM-light structure as the cause, and Whatnot sells collectibles and trading cards in a category that grew strongly over the same period. The clip does not claim causation, but anyone copying the model should know the evidence is one company's structure alongside its own reported growth.
What does the 73-second clip leave out?
The clip is about 1.4% of the episode. The chapter list shows what surrounds it:
- "'We regret that product management exists': what it means and why" from 2:40
- "When specialization makes sense, and when it doesn't" from 8:30
- "How Whatnot structures its PM org" from 15:20
- "The shift to senior ICs doing IC work"
- "Advice for PMs struggling in today's market"
- "How AI has transformed work at Whatnot"
- "Why core PM skills are the most durable in an AI world"
A PM who sees only the clip gets the provocation without the conditions for when PMs are worth having. The full episode is on YouTube and Spotify.
Bottom line
Tom Verrilli argues that product management is a trade learned through practice, that engineers and designers should own more product decisions, and that PMs still matter on the projects that need to go really well. The caption "PMs are a muscle, not a job" reverses that. His view is experience-based, and Whatnot's growth numbers are self-reported.
Sources
- Lenny's Podcast episode on YouTube - the full episode and chapters
- Lenny's Newsletter episode page - episode summary
- Tom Verrilli, Shoptalk speaker page - his current and past roles
- Twitch blog open letter, 25 January 2023 - his Twitch CPO role
- Airtree advisor profile - career history
- Tubefilter on Whatnot's Series G - funding and growth figures
- Whatnot product manager listing, Built In - Whatnot's PM hiring
- The episode on Spotify - audio version
Published September 25, 2026. Based on a TikTok by @tech.podcast0. Full video notes (markdown)