<- all tokdocs

The Presence and Emotion Sales 2x2: What the Research Shows

By , founder of Mavric and Apso

View on TikTok ->

A TikTok from @danidocumented draws a 2x2 grid with presence on one axis and emotion on the other, and says "the greatest salespeople live" at high presence and low emotion. The curiosity advice inside the video has solid research behind it. The grid itself does not match any published model, and the one study that tested salesperson performance with a 2x2 used different axes and found a 270 percent commission gap.

What the presence and emotion 2x2 claims

The video draws a cross with "P" on the vertical axis and "E" on the horizontal axis, then fills the four cells with a crying face, a "zzz", a ghost and an eye. The spoken argument is that high presence with low emotion makes people feel seen, and that this quadrant is where top salespeople operate.

It also argues that opening with "how old are you? Where do you live? Where do you work?" shows you care about status. In the video's words: "If you're more interested in somebody's status than their story, you are not being curious. You're being comparative."

The grid carries no numbers, no axis labels for high or low, and no citation, author or study.

Is there a published presence and emotion model?

Social psychology does have a dominant two-dimensional model of how people judge each other, and its axes are warmth and competence. Fiske, Cuddy, Glick and Xu published the stereotype content model in the Journal of Personality and Social Psychology (volume 82, issue 6, pages 878 to 902, June 2002). They tested it across nine samples covering gender, ethnicity, race, class, age and disability groups.

A search for a prior "presence by emotion" sales framework turned up nothing. That does not prove the grid is original. It does mean the 2x2 in the video is not the validated one, and the video gives viewers no way to check it.

Are status questions a sign of judging people?

The same 2002 paper found that "status predicted competence, and competition predicted low warmth." Asking where someone works is how people gather the status information that drives a competence judgment. The researchers treat that as ordinary social perception across every group they tested, not a flaw specific to bad networkers.

The video's point holds in a narrower form. Stopping at status gives you one dimension. The research ties being liked to the warmth side, which is where the next finding comes in.

Does asking questions make people like you more?

Yes. This is the best-supported claim in the video. Huang, Yeomans, Brooks, Minson and Gino published "It doesn't hurt to ask: Question-asking increases liking" in the Journal of Personality and Social Psychology (volume 113, issue 3, pages 430 to 452, September 2017). Their abstract reports that "people who ask more questions, particularly follow-up questions, are better liked by their conversation partners."

The mechanism is responsiveness, which the authors define as "listening, understanding, validation, and care." They tested it in online get-to-know-you chats and in face-to-face speed dating. That is close to what the video calls making people feel seen and heard. The difference is that the paper measures a countable behavior, the rate of follow-up questions. The research supports asking the second question. It does not support the quadrant.

What makes the best salespeople, according to research?

Kidwell, Hasford, Turner, Hardesty and Zablah published "Emotional Calibration and Salesperson Performance" in the Journal of Marketing (volume 85, issue 6, pages 141 to 161, 2021). Their grid crosses emotional intelligence (the ability to perceive, understand and manage emotions) with emotional self-efficacy (confidence in that ability).

Baylor's Keller Center summary reports that "Emotionally calibrated salespeople outperform all others." They "earn an average commission more than 270% higher than salespeople who were highly confident of their emotional skills, yet lacked these skills."

The two mismatched profiles also differ from the video's drawings. High skill with low confidence produces "negative avoidance emotions like anxiety and nervousness." Low skill with high confidence produces someone who "may appear inattentive, with off-putting displays of excitement."

The video's caption asks viewers to judge for themselves whether they are high presence and low emotion. That is uncalibrated self-assessment, which is the exact variable the 2021 paper measured.

Should salespeople show less emotion?

It depends on which emotion. James Russell's circumplex model (Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, volume 39, issue 6, 1980) separates affect into valence and arousal. The video's single "E" axis mixes them: the crying face is high arousal and negative, the "zzz" is low arousal, and the ghost shows no emotion at all.

Low anxiety is worth aiming for. Verbeke and Bagozzi studied sales call anxiety in the Journal of Marketing (volume 64, issue 3, 2000). Brooks and Schweitzer found that anxious negotiators make lower first offers, exit early and earn less profit (Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes, volume 115, issue 1, 2011).

Low displayed warmth is a different matter. Pugh found that employees' displayed positive emotion transfers to customers and raises their ratings of service quality (Academy of Management Journal, volume 44, issue 5, 2001). Holding all emotion flat would suppress the display that study found helps.

That collapse explains why the video describes the high presence, high emotion cell as both attractive ("People are drawn to you") and tiring ("but it's exhausting").

Bottom line

  • Asking more follow-up questions makes people like you more, and that part of the video is well supported.
  • The presence and emotion grid has no published source. The tested sales 2x2 crosses emotional skill with confidence in that skill.
  • "Low emotion" works as advice about anxiety. It works against you if it means hiding positive emotion from customers.

Sources

Published October 22, 2026. Based on a TikTok by @danidocumented. Full video notes (markdown)