Spotify Wrapped-Style Review Awards for Cold Outreach: Does It Work?
By Matt Cullerton, founder of Mavric and Apso
A TikTok from @angusthenontechnical suggests a marketing agency build a Spotify Wrapped-style award for a prospect, such as "fastest service" among Chattanooga med spas, by scraping Google reviews and having AI tag them. The prompts shown on screen are careful and include a minimum sample size. The Claude session the video shows, though, ends with "No citywide ranking," and scraping Google Maps reviews in bulk runs against Google's terms.
Why do year-in-review recaps work?
The video's premise is that recaps succeed because they hand people a flattering, shareable result, and that Spotify started the trend. The dates support that. Spotify Wrapped was "first launched in December 2016," after a smaller "Year in Music" campaign in 2015. Duolingo sent its first recap email in December 2019 and moved it into the app in 2020. TechCrunch reported Apple Music Replay's launch on 13 November 2019, calling it "similar in some ways to Spotify's popular year-end review, known as Wrapped."
The video's twist is to make the recap for a prospect's business and send it as cold outreach.
How does the review award workflow work?
The video shows two prompts. The first, "COLLECT THE PUBLIC DATA," says to build a list of med spas in Chattanooga, deduplicate them by place ID, collect review text, date and source URL, record the fetch date and what could not be accessed, save businesses.csv and reviews.csv, and "Never invent missing rows."
The second, "TAG, CALCULATE, MAKE AWARDS," says to:
- Tag every review for explicit mentions of service speed, repeat visits and staff names, keeping the evidence quote and row ID.
- Mark uncertain rows unknown, then audit a sample by hand and fix inconsistent tags.
- Count matching reviews per business in code over the same date window, and "require at least 30 usable reviews."
- "Name winners only within the collected sample," reporting ties, exclusions and source links, with "No causal claims."
The scraper on screen is Apify's Google Maps Reviews Scraper (compass/google-maps-reviews-scraper), priced "from $0.30 / 1,000 scraped reviews," with 8,602 monthly active users. Its description reads "Extract all reviews of Google Maps places using place URLs."
Does the demo support a citywide award?
No. The voiceover says AI can calculate the "most reviews that mention the speed of service of every med spa in Chattanooga," over a card reading "CHATTANOOGA WINNER, SPEED OF SERVICE, LARIMAR MEDSPA." The count printed on that card does not appear in any table, prompt output or scraper run in the video.
The Claude session the video does show, titled "Larimar Medspa review tagging" and running Opus 5.5, tags five review excerpts. Only one, "right at your appointment time," mentions speed. It ends with "Count: 1 of 5 mention speed." and "5 excerpts. No citywide ranking." Another reply in the same session says: "with 5 excerpts and 1 yes, Larimar would fall below any reasonable threshold and stay unranked," and "Right now that is 5 excerpts from one Chattanooga medspa, which supports no citywide claim."
That also breaks the video's own prompt, which requires 30 usable reviews and limits winners to the collected sample. No terminal, scraper run, CSV or code count appears anywhere in the clip.
The one card number that traces to something on screen is "355 public reviews" for Larimar Medspa, which matches the "Larimar Medspa 5.0 (355)" result in Google Maps. To the creator's credit, every award card is stamped "EXAMPLE DATA • CONCEPT AWARD" or "DESIGN CONCEPT," and the outreach email and Instagram story are labeled "MOCKUP."
How do you stop AI from making up review counts?
The video asks "wouldn't AI just hallucinate a bunch of these findings?" and answers with tagging each row. The method visible in the Claude session has four parts:
- Give each review a stable row ID "tied to its source URL and retrieval date, so anyone can trace a tag back to the exact text."
- Tag only on explicit wording ("right at your appointment time" = yes; "glowing instantly" = no) and store the quoted evidence with the tag.
- "Count tags in code, not by hand," against a minimum sample set in advance.
- State the scope with every result: which businesses, how many excerpts each, the source and the date.
Is scraping Google reviews allowed?
The video never mentions terms of service, and the Apify listing says nothing about it either. Google's Maps and Earth Additional Terms of Service prohibit users from doing "mass download or create bulk feeds of the content" and from using Google Maps "to create or augment any other mapping-related dataset (including a mapping or navigation dataset, business listings database, mailing list, or telemarketing list)." Google's older Maps APIs terms also limited caching to "no more than 30 calendar days."
Do FTC review rules apply to awards like this?
The FTC's rule on consumer reviews and testimonials, 16 CFR Part 465, took effect on 21 October 2024. Section 465.6 bars an advertiser from representing "that a website, organization, or entity it controls, owns, or operates provides independent reviews or opinions" about its own category. An agency that creates a "LOCAL LEGENDS 2026" award brand and hands out "CHATTANOOGA WINNER" cards is operating that kind of entity, so the sample behind each claim matters.
Bottom line
A personalized recap built from a business's real reviews can be a good outreach hook, and the video's written prompts include the right safeguards. Follow them: at least 30 reviews per business, winners named only within your sample, counts in code, and sources shown. Check Google's terms before scraping Maps reviews, and note that the demo shown supports no award.
Sources
- Spotify Wrapped (Wikipedia): launch history.
- How your Wrapped is made (Spotify Newsroom): 2025 launch and data window.
- Apple Music Replay launch (TechCrunch): November 2019 launch.
- Year in Review behind the scenes (Duolingo): Duolingo's recap history.
- Strava Year in Sport report (Strava Press): the aggregate report.
- Google Maps Reviews Scraper (Apify): the scraper shown.
- Google Maps and Google Earth Additional Terms of Service: prohibited conduct.
- Maps APIs Terms of Service, 2018 archive: caching and bulk download limits.
- Anthropic models overview: Claude Opus 5.5.
- FTC final rule on fake reviews: the review rule.
- Federal Register: consumer reviews rule: publication of 16 CFR Part 465.
- angussewell.com: the creator's site.
Published October 27, 2026. Based on a TikTok by @angusthenontechnical. Full video notes (markdown)