<- all tokdocs

Karpathy's LLM Explanation Ladder and the ASD-STE100 Standard

By , founder of Mavric and Apso

View on TikTok ->

Andrej Karpathy posted a four-step ladder for getting better explanations from a language model: ask for text in ASD-STE100 controlled English, then a diagram, then an HTML page, then an explainer video. A TikTok from @agenticengineering summarizes it accurately, but misspells his name as "Andrew," renders the standard as "ASD-ST100," and leaves out two things worth knowing. The body that maintains ASD-STE100 says it was not written for general-purpose writing, and warns that AI text can look compliant without being compliant.

What is Karpathy's explanation ladder?

The post is at x.com/karpathy/status/2105819303471976479, created at 00:37 UTC on October 2, 2026, which is the evening of October 1 in US Pacific time. The video posted about 13 hours later.

The four steps, in his words:

  1. Writing. "Ask your LLM to explain something in ASD-STE100."
  2. Diagrams. "Instead of writing, ask your LLM to create a diagram."
  3. Web pages. "Ask for output 'in HTML' to get a beautiful, interactive webpage."
  4. Explainer videos. His prompt: "Create a 3b1b style video explainer on X. Use my ElevenLabs API key for audio narration."

He also hedges the first step, suggesting "80% of the way to ASD-STE100 because the spec is quite stringent," and the video keeps that.

The video drops two details. Karpathy notes the video step needs an API key, "or you can ask your LLM to find you decent free alternatives that use your local compute." ElevenLabs' text-to-speech API does require one. He also closes by saying you can now ask for "large, custom, discardable software artifacts ... that would have never made sense to create before."

"3b1b" refers to 3Blue1Brown, Grant Sanderson's math animation channel. Manim, the Python animation library he wrote, is now maintained by the Manim Community under the MIT license.

What is ASD-STE100?

ASD-STE100 is Simplified Technical English, a controlled language for maintenance documentation. The video describes it as "originally developed for aerospace maintenance documentation" and says it "limits vocabulary and sentence structure." Both hold up.

The official site says STE "is a controlled natural language developed in the late 1970s (originally as AECMA Simplified English) to help the users of English-language maintenance documentation understand what they read." It "was initially applicable to commercial aviation" and "was first released in 1986 as AECMA Document, PSC-85-16598." The FAQ dates the project to 1979 and the working group to June 30, 1983.

Three facts the video skips:

  • The current version is Issue 9, dated January 2025. With Issue 9 it became an international standard. Older pages on the same site still say Issue 8, April 2021.
  • The dictionary holds about 900 approved words, per the FAQ.
  • It is free. The FAQ says it "is available to everyone free of charge" as a PDF, requested from the downloads page.

Is ASD-STE100 meant for explaining concepts?

Not by its owners' account. The FAQ says "STE was developed to make maintenance documentation easier to read," and "It is not intended for general-purpose writing, such as international correspondence." It adds that "many of its principles (for example, short sentences, one topic per sentence, and the use of the active voice) can be effectively adopted and applied in other writing contexts." Asked whether STE can be used to teach English, the FAQ says "No."

So the principles transfer, but asking a model to explain a concept in STE is outside the standard's stated scope. Karpathy's "80%" hedge fits that.

Can an LLM write compliant Simplified Technical English?

The standard's maintenance group says to be careful. Its white paper on ASD-STE100 and AI, dated June 2026, lists automated compliance checks as a benefit "with varying levels of accuracy." Under challenges it lists "Variable reliability and factual accuracy of AI-generated content" and "Potential compromise of terminology control."

The downloads page summary is blunter: "AI-generated text can appear clear, authoritative, and consistent with STE, even when it does not correctly apply the rules and vocabulary of the standard. Plausibility must not be confused with verified compliance." The white paper concludes: "AI should assist, not replace, human authors."

A model asked to imitate STE can produce text that reads well and still breaks the rules.

Are diagrams really easier to understand than text?

The video argues "a good visual is simply easier to understand than another five paragraphs." Neither the video nor Karpathy cites evidence. Research supports a version of the claim.

Richard Mayer, in a 2023 chapter for an American Psychological Association Division 2 volume, reports that "in a series of 13 experimental comparisons" students did "much better on a transfer test when they learn from words and graphics than from words alone," with "a median effect size of d = 1.35." His example is a narrated animation of a tire pump.

Those studies used short lessons on physical systems such as pumps, brakes and lightning, with students as subjects. A broader 2025 meta-analysis by Cromley and Chen in Educational Research Review covered 92 articles, 181 studies and 591 effects. It found an "overall effect was g = 0.37," moderated by every factor tested. Text combined with diagrams held up well, and virtual reality showed no significant effect.

The diagram step has the strongest research behind it, with a medium average effect. The video's claim that a model can "build the explanation around how you learn best" has no cited source.

Bottom line

Karpathy's ladder is a useful prompting pattern, and the video reports its order and hedge correctly. Treat ASD-STE100 as a style to borrow rather than a standard a model will meet, and check its output against the free Issue 9 PDF if compliance matters. The video step needs an API key or a local alternative.

Sources

Published October 2, 2026. Based on a TikTok by @agenticengineering. Full video notes (markdown)