Is the Bible Monotheistic? Dan McClellan on Other Gods in Scripture
By Matt Cullerton, founder of Mavric and Apso
Dan McClellan, a scholar of the Bible and religion, argues that the Bible is not monotheistic in the modern sense. In his reading, the Bible acknowledges the existence of multiple gods from beginning to end, and no passage literally denies that other gods exist. He calls monotheism a post-biblical philosophical innovation.
McClellan makes the case in a short TikTok posted as @maklelan. His argument has three parts: what the biblical text says, what monotheism depends on, and why people read it into the Bible anyway.
Does the Bible deny that other gods exist?
According to McClellan, no passage does. The Bible has a lot of rhetoric about the incomparability of Adonai. It says no one compares, and it calls other gods "nothing" and "less than nothing."
McClellan says this is rhetorical language and not a denial that those gods exist. The Bible uses the same kind of rhetoric about Assyria and Babylon in relation to Israel's God. Calling something "like nothing" because it is so inferior is a common rhetorical device. It does not claim the thing is absent from the world.
McClellan also points out that multiple passages explicitly acknowledge the existence and even the power of other gods. Any passage read as denying other gods would flatly contradict those texts.
What is creation ex nihilo, and why does it matter?
Creation ex nihilo is the doctrine that God created everything from nothing. McClellan argues that monotheism as it is defined today depends on this doctrine. If one God made everything that exists out of nothing, there is no room for other gods with power of their own.
The timing is the problem for reading monotheism into the Bible. McClellan says the doctrine of creation ex nihilo did not develop until around 170 CE, well after the biblical period.
How did earlier texts describe creation?
Before creation ex nihilo, Greek philosophical frameworks described matter as existing in states of "being" or "non-being." Which state it was in depended on whether it had form and function.
McClellan says 2 Maccabees 7:28 and parts of the New Testament use this framework. When those texts talk about things coming from what is not, they describe formless matter. They are not describing creation from absolute nothing.
When did the word "monotheism" appear?
The term came even later than the doctrine it rests on. McClellan traces it to the Cambridge Platonist Henry More, around 1660 CE.
That gives a rough order of events in his argument:
- The biblical texts, which acknowledge other gods
- Creation ex nihilo, developed around 170 CE
- The word "monotheism," coined by Henry More around 1660 CE
Because the concept builds on creation ex nihilo, McClellan argues it could not have existed when the Bible was composed.
Why do people read monotheism into the Bible?
McClellan's answer is ideological continuity. Believers want their monotheistic faith to be rooted in their inspired scripture.
To keep that link, scholars have developed different strategies. Some read monotheism into the biblical text. Others redefine monotheism so that it can be found there. McClellan rejects both approaches as projecting a later idea back onto older texts.
Where to read more from McClellan
McClellan has published an essay on monotheism in the Oxford Research Encyclopedia of Religion. He also has an edited volume forthcoming from a conference he helped organize, titled "The Meanings and Ends of Monotheism."
Bottom line
McClellan's case is that the Bible acknowledges other gods throughout and that its "nothing" language is incomparability rhetoric, the same kind it uses for Assyria and Babylon. Monotheism depends on creation ex nihilo, which he dates to around 170 CE, and the word itself to around 1660 CE. In his view, finding monotheism in the Bible means projecting a later idea back onto it.
Sources
- Oxford Research Encyclopedia of Religion - where McClellan's essay on monotheism is published
Published May 25, 2026. Based on a TikTok by @maklelan. Full video notes (markdown)