Barry Trotz on Ovechkin and the 2018 Cup: The Columbus Talk, Checked
By Matt Cullerton, founder of Mavric and Apso
Former Capitals coach Barry Trotz says a sit-down with Alex Ovechkin in Columbus, after Washington fell behind 2-0 in the 2018 first round, set up the team's Stanley Cup run. In a clip from the Ryan Ripken Show (@ryanripkenshow), every date and series result he describes checks out. The cause-and-effect is thinner: Ovechkin's shot-blocking rate barely changed, and in 2018 Trotz described the key "redefine yourself" conversation as happening the summer before.
Who is Barry Trotz?
Hockey-Reference lists Trotz with 914 career regular-season wins across Nashville (1998-99 to 2013-14), Washington (2014-15 to 2017-18) and the New York Islanders (2018-19 to 2021-22). Wikipedia gives his Capitals hire as May 26, 2014 and his resignation over a contract dispute on June 18, 2018, eleven days after the Cup.
His line "I haven't won a cup" was true at the time. He had none in fifteen Nashville seasons or his first three in Washington, and 2018 remains his only title.
He became Nashville's general manager on July 1, 2023. NHL.com reported on February 2, 2026 that he would retire as GM and stay on as an adviser through 2026-27. Wikipedia dates the handover to Chris MacFarland on June 2, 2026.
Were the Capitals really down 2-0 to Columbus in 2018?
Yes. Wikipedia's 2018 playoffs page lists Columbus winning 4-3 in overtime on April 12 and 5-4 in overtime on April 15, both in Washington. The Capitals then won 3-2 in double overtime on April 17, 4-1 on April 19, 4-3 in overtime on April 21 and 6-3 on April 23. Game 3 was the first game in Columbus, so a talk there after going down 0-2 fits the schedule.
ESPN's Game 3 recap says Lars Eller scored nine minutes into the second overtime, Braden Holtby stopped 33 shots, and it was Ovechkin's 100th career playoff game.
Washington then beat Pittsburgh 4-2, Tampa Bay 4-3 and Vegas 4-1, clinching on June 7, 2018. Ovechkin won the Conn Smythe. The 2017-18 season page notes Washington became the fourth champion to lose its first two games at home.
Did Ovechkin always score in the playoffs?
Largely, yes. Trotz says "You always score in the playoffs, but you're going to have to do more. You're going to have to block shots." Hockey-Reference shows 46 playoff goals across nine postseasons before 2018, with only one year below four.
In 2018 he scored 15 goals with 12 assists in 24 games. CBS Sports reported he led Washington with five goals against Columbus and became the 60th player to reach 50 postseason goals.
Did Ovechkin block more shots in 2018?
More in total, not per game. He blocked 14 shots in 24 playoff games in 2018, 0.58 per game. In the three prior postseasons he blocked 7 in 14 games (0.50), 5 in 12 (0.42) and 8 in 13 (0.62). The total rose because the run lasted longer.
Greg Wyshynski's ESPN piece the day after the Cup made a narrower point about visible effort: "He blocked shots. He joyously celebrated his own goals and those of his teammates."
When did Trotz have the "redefine yourself" talk with Ovechkin?
That same ESPN piece has Trotz describing a visit to Ovechkin in the summer of 2017, telling him "as you get older, those opportunities and things you did when you were 23, you can't do when you're 33." The 2026 clip places the key talk in Columbus in April 2018, focused on shot-blocking and being "the guy to follow."
Both conversations may have happened. Trotz is the only source for either, so the Columbus sit-down is his recollection rather than a documented event.
What else turned the Columbus series?
CBS Sports lists two changes the clip leaves out. Holtby replaced Philipp Grubauer in goal for Game 3 and posted a .932 save percentage, and Washington's power play went 9 for 27 (33.3%) against Columbus's 4 for 24. Trotz's "Once he did that, he did all the things that didn't take talent, and we took off" folds a goalie change, a special-teams edge and an Ovechkin scoring streak into one captain's decision.
Did Ovechkin and Crosby save the NHL after the lockout?
Trotz says "Him and Sid, to me, saved the game after the lockout," and marks it as opinion. The timeline holds. Wikipedia dates the lockout from September 16, 2004 to July 22, 2005, with the full season cancelled and 1,230 games lost. Pittsburgh won the 2005 lottery and drafted Sidney Crosby, and Ovechkin debuted on October 5, 2005. Both were rookies in the first season back.
The pressure Trotz describes ("I could write my name in the air, it was so thick") followed back-to-back strong seasons. Washington went 56-18-8 in 2015-16 and 55-19-8 in 2016-17, winning two Presidents' Trophies, and lost to Pittsburgh in the second round both years.
Why is Trotz talking about this now?
ESPN reported on October 5, 2026 that Ovechkin, 41, will retire after the 2026-27 season: "I know in my heart it is the right decision." ESPN put his career total at 929 goals. The Ryan Ripken Show episode with Trotz aired October 12, 2026, according to Listen Notes.
Bottom line
Trotz's story is accurate on every date, score and series. The 2018 turnaround also involved a goalie change and a strong power play, and Ovechkin's per-game shot-blocking stayed in his usual range. The Columbus talk is a coach's memory of what mattered, told eight years later.
Sources
- Barry Trotz coaching record, Hockey-Reference - wins and season records
- Barry Trotz on Wikipedia - career dates
- 2018 Stanley Cup playoffs on Wikipedia - series results
- ESPN Game 3 recap, April 17, 2018 - double-overtime win in Columbus
- Alex Ovechkin, Hockey-Reference - playoff goals and blocked shots
- CBS Sports, April 24, 2018 - why Columbus lost the series
- ESPN, June 8, 2018 - Trotz's summer 2017 account
- ESPN on Ovechkin's retirement, October 5, 2026 - retirement announcement
- NHL.com on Trotz's retirement plans - GM retirement
- Ryan Ripken Show on Listen Notes - source episode
- 2017-18 Capitals season on Wikipedia - Cup season details
- 2016-17 Capitals season on Wikipedia - prior season
- 2004-05 NHL lockout on Wikipedia - lockout dates
- NHL.com on Trotz retiring as GM - Trotz on the decision
- Alexander Ovechkin on Wikipedia - debut date
- Yahoo Sports on Ovechkin's announcement - announcement timing
- List of Nashville Predators general managers - GM handover date
Published October 14, 2026. Based on a TikTok by @ryanripkenshow. Full video notes (markdown)