---
title: "Minto Pyramid Prompt for Claude: How to Use It and What to Fix"
date: "2026-09-25"
video_id: "7689297926992039199"
tiktok_url: "https://www.tiktok.com/@bengusberg/video/7689297926992039199"
creator: "@bengusberg"
category: "AI"
tags: ["minto pyramid", "claude prompts", "barbara minto", "business writing", "claude opus 5.5"]
excerpt: "A viral prompt asks Claude to rewrite text with Barbara Minto's Pyramid Principle. Here is the exact prompt, what Minto's rules say, and where the advice slips."
---
The Minto Pyramid Principle is a writing structure from former McKinsey consultant Barbara Minto: lead with your conclusion, back it with grouped reasons, and put the evidence underneath. A TikTok from @bengusberg shares a Claude prompt that rewrites text into that structure. The prompt is sound, but the voiceover says "three reasons" while the prompt asks for 2-4, and the clip never shows Claude's output.

## What is the Minto Pyramid Principle?

Minto's own site states it this way: "The Minto Pyramid Principle says that your thinking will be easy for a reader to grasp if you present the ideas organized as a pyramid under a single point."

Her three rules govern how the levels relate:

- Ideas in each grouping must be the same kind of idea.
- Ideas at any level must summarize the ideas grouped below them.
- Ideas in each grouping must be logically ordered.

The pyramid graphic in the video comes from untools.co, whose card reads "Make your communication more efficient and clear." Untools sets no required number of supporting arguments and notes that the detail layer can be skipped when the key arguments carry the point.

## Who is Barbara Minto?

The clip calls her a "legendary McKinsey consultant," which checks out. Minto joined McKinsey in Cleveland in 1963 as the firm's first female MBA hire, moved to London in 1966, and left in 1973. She published *The Pyramid Principle: Logic in Writing and Thinking* in 1985 and *The Minto Pyramid Principle: Logic in Writing, Thinking and Problem Solving* in 1996.

## The Minto prompt for Claude

The prompt appears on screen in the Claude composer:

```
Rewrite this using the Minto Pyramid Principle. Start with the conclusion, add 2-4 supporting
reasons, and then end with our supporting evidence. Remove anything that is not necessary to
meet the principle's guidelines, and let me know if anything is missing.
```

"Our supporting evidence" reads as a typo for "your." The last instruction, asking Claude to flag what is missing, is the most useful line, because it produces feedback on the argument instead of only a rewrite.

The composer shows Claude Opus 5.5 at "Medium" effort. Anthropic released Opus 5.5 on 2026-09-22, three days before the video, and its documented default effort is `medium`, so the screen shows the standard setup.

## Should you ask for three reasons or 2-4?

The voiceover says "Number one, start with your conclusion. Two, add three reasons. Three, end with your supporting evidence or data." The prompt on screen says "2-4 supporting reasons."

The range is closer to Minto. Her rules are about grouping and summary, not a set count at each level. Three reasons is a common convention that travels with the framework. If you copy the prompt, keep the range so Claude does not invent a third reason or drop a fourth to hit a number.

## How to use the prompt

The prompt starts with "Rewrite this," so it needs text to work on. The composer in the clip holds only the instruction, with nothing pasted or attached, and the clip never sends it.

1. Paste your draft email or document into Claude, or attach the file.
2. Add the prompt above it, with "your" in place of "our."
3. Read the list of missing pieces Claude reports before using the rewrite.
4. Check that each reason actually summarizes the evidence under it, which is Minto's second rule.

The video promises the result will make every doc and email "sound like an expert" and like "a McKinsey consultant." It shows no Claude response, before-and-after, or sample rewrite, so judge the output on your own drafts.

## Should you add it to your custom instructions?

The voiceover says "You can even add this to your custom instructions if you want." Anthropic's personalization docs call the account-wide setting "Instructions for Claude," alongside project instructions and skills.

The bigger issue is fit. A prompt that begins "Rewrite this" is built for one turn against a specific input. As an account-wide instruction, it would apply to every conversation, including ones with nothing to rewrite. A project instruction or a skill limited to writing tasks is a better home for it.

The composer also shows the Chat and Cowork toggle. Cowork, Anthropic's agent for general knowledge work, launched on desktop in January 2026 and reached web and mobile in July 2026.

## Bottom line

The prompt is a useful way to restructure a draft so the conclusion comes first, and the request to flag gaps is its strongest part. Keep the "2-4 supporting reasons" range rather than the spoken "three," paste in the text you want rewritten, and save it as a project instruction or skill instead of an account-wide setting.

## Sources

- [Barbara Minto (Wikipedia)](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Barbara_Minto): her McKinsey career and books.
- [barbaraminto.com](https://www.barbaraminto.com/): Minto's statement of the principle.
- [Minto Pyramid on Untools](https://untools.co/minto-pyramid/): the pyramid card shown in the video.
- [The Pyramid Principle, Part One (StrategyU)](https://strategyu.co/pyramid-principle-partone/): Minto's three rules.
- [Claude models overview](https://platform.claude.com/docs/en/about-claude/models/overview): Opus 5.5 model ID and default effort.
- [Introducing Claude Opus 5.5](https://www.anthropic.com/claude-opus-5-5): release date and effort levels.
- [Understanding Claude's personalization features](https://support.claude.com/en/articles/10185728-understanding-claude-s-personalization-features): the "Instructions for Claude" setting.
- [Claude Cowork expands to mobile and web (TechCrunch)](https://techcrunch.com/2026/07/07/the-coding-agent-wars-are-spilling-into-the-rest-of-the-office-claude-cowork/): Cowork's rollout.


## Video description and verification notes

**This is a 45-second selfie clip posted by @bengusberg on 2026-09-25, at 1080x1920, carrying 162,400 views, 7,263 likes, 65 comments, 1,726 reposts, and 9,056 saves at the time of capture. The transcript runs 181 words across 18 subtitle cues, and 23 frames were extracted at 2-second intervals. Every frame shows the same speaker in a corner with grey acoustic felt on the left and vertical wood slats on the right, with burned-in captions in white and yellow at the bottom. Five distinct overlay cards appear. Frame 001 shows a dark navy card reading "McKinsey & Company" in white serif. Frame 002 shows a low-resolution card with the watermark "untools.co" in the top right and a three-tier grey pyramid. Frame 008 shows the same card at full resolution reading "Minto Pyramid" with the subhead "Make your communication more efficient and clear." Frame 009 shows a grey-background portrait of a blonde woman in a checked jacket while the caption reads "MCKINSEY CONSULTANT BARBARA". Frames 011 through 013 build a blue-box tree diagram labeled "Main Recommendation/Goal/Idea" at the top, "Supporting Arguments" across three linked boxes in the middle, and "Supporting Data / Insights / Conclusions" under nine boxes at the base. Frames 017 and 018 show a Claude composer with the full prompt typed and not yet sent, a Chat and Cowork toggle, a "+" attachment button, a model label reading "Opus 5.5" beside "Medium", a red send arrow, and a row beneath reading "Project or folder", "Manual", and "Output".**

## The prompt is the whole artifact, and it is fully legible on screen

Frames 017 and 018 hold the composer steady for roughly four seconds. The text cursor sits after the final period, which means the prompt was typed and never submitted on camera. Reproduced verbatim from the screen:

```
Rewrite this using the Minto Pyramid Principle. Start with the conclusion, add 2-4 supporting
reasons, and then end with our supporting evidence. Remove anything that is not necessary to
meet the principle's guidelines, and let me know if anything is missing.
```

Two details are worth preserving exactly. The prompt says "our supporting evidence" where "your" reads as the intended word. The prompt also asks Claude to flag gaps, which is the only instruction in it that produces something other than a rewrite.

The surrounding interface is checkable. The model label reads "Opus 5.5" with "Medium" next to it. Anthropic released Claude Opus 5.5 on 2026-09-22 under the API ID `claude-opus-5-5`, three days before this clip was posted, and Anthropic's own model table lists Opus 5.5 with a default effort of `medium`. The on-screen state is the shipping default. The Chat and Cowork toggle is consistent with Cowork, Anthropic's agent for general knowledge work, which launched on desktop in January 2026 and reached web and mobile in July 2026.

## The audio and the prompt give two different numbers

The voiceover states the framework in three parts:

> Number one, start with your conclusion.
> Two, add three reasons.
> Three, end with your supporting evidence or data.

Frame 012 reinforces this with a single yellow "3" caption and a raised three-finger gesture. The prompt on screen asks for "2-4 supporting reasons". A viewer who copies the prompt gets a range. A viewer who follows the spoken instruction gets a fixed count.

The range is the better instruction. Barbara Minto's actual rules govern the relationship between levels rather than the headcount at any one level. Her three rules are that ideas in each grouping must be the same kind of idea, that ideas at any level must summarize the ideas grouped below them, and that ideas in each grouping must be logically ordered. Untools, which published the pyramid card shown in frames 002 and 008, states no required number and notes that the detail layer can be skipped when the key arguments carry the point. The "three reasons" line is a convention that travels with the framework, not a rule inside it.

## The McKinsey attribution is accurate, and the diagram is not McKinsey's

The clip says the principle was "created by legendary McKinsey consultant Barbara Minto." That checks out. Minto joined McKinsey in Cleveland in 1963 as the firm's first female MBA hire, moved to London in 1966, and stayed until 1973. She published *The Pyramid Principle: Logic in Writing and Thinking* in 1985 and *The Minto Pyramid Principle: Logic in Writing, Thinking and Problem Solving* in 1996. Her own site states the core idea directly: "The Minto Pyramid Principle says that your thinking will be easy for a reader to grasp if you present the ideas organized as a pyramid under a single point."

The opening claim, "Every McKinsey consultant learns this one writing framework," is the part I could not confirm. Secondary consulting-industry sources say it is taught in McKinsey's onboarding program, and McKinsey's alumni site hosts an interview with Minto about MECE, but that page timed out on repeated fetch attempts and I have no primary McKinsey source describing the curriculum. The visual evidence in the clip does not support the claim either. The "McKinsey & Company" card in frame 001 is a wordmark with no document behind it, and the pyramid graphic in frames 002 and 008 comes from untools.co, a third-party mental-model site.

## The clip never shows Claude's output

The stated payoff is "now every doc and email I write sounds like an expert" and "Claude will then polish your writing to always sound like a McKinsey consultant every time you write anything." No frame in the clip shows a Claude response. The composer appears in exactly two frames, both with the prompt unsent. There is no before-and-after, no sample document, and no rewritten paragraph anywhere in the 23 frames.

This matters because the prompt is a transform that needs an input. It begins with "Rewrite this," which assumes text is already pasted or a file is already attached. The clip shows an empty composer with only the instruction in it.

## "Custom instructions" is not the name of the setting it points you to

The voiceover says:

> You can even add this to your custom instructions if you want.

Anthropic's personalization documentation names the account-wide setting "Instructions for Claude," alongside project instructions and skills. "Custom instructions" is widely used informally, so a viewer will find the right screen, but the label in the product differs.

There is also a practical problem with the advice that the clip does not raise. A prompt whose first word is "Rewrite this" is written for a single turn against a specific input. Promoting it to an account-wide instruction applies it to every conversation, including ones where nothing has been pasted to rewrite.

## Key Takeaways

- The reusable artifact is one prompt, legible in frames 017 and 018, asking Claude to rewrite text using the Minto Pyramid Principle with the conclusion first, 2-4 supporting reasons, supporting evidence last, non-essential content removed, and gaps flagged.
- The spoken "three reasons" and the on-screen "2-4 supporting reasons" do not match. The written range is closer to Minto's published rules, which constrain how levels relate rather than how many items sit at each level.
- Barbara Minto's biography as stated in the clip is accurate. She was McKinsey's first female MBA hire in 1963 and published the principle in book form in 1985.
- The on-screen Claude state is current and correct. Opus 5.5 shipped on 2026-09-22 and its documented default effort is `medium`, which is exactly what the composer shows.
- Unverified: the claim that "every McKinsey consultant learns this one writing framework." McKinsey's alumni page on Minto timed out on repeated fetches, and I found no primary McKinsey source describing its onboarding curriculum. Also unverified: that the technique makes writing "sound like an expert," since the clip shows no Claude output at all.
- Unverified: whether Whisper mis-transcribed anything. At every point where a burned-in caption was readable, the caption matched the Whisper transcript word for word, including "$4 MILLION", "MINTO PYRAMID PRINCIPLE", and "I'M BEN GUSBERG".

## Resources

- [Barbara Minto (Wikipedia)](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Barbara_Minto) - confirms she was McKinsey's first female MBA hire in 1963 in Cleveland, moved to London in 1966, left in 1973, and published the two book editions in 1985 and 1996.
- [barbaraminto.com](https://www.barbaraminto.com/) - Minto's own statement of the principle, quoted above.
- [Minto Pyramid on Untools](https://untools.co/minto-pyramid/) - the exact card shown in frames 002 and 008, including the subhead "Make your communication more efficient and clear." Specifies no required number of supporting arguments.
- [The Pyramid Principle, Part One (StrategyU)](https://strategyu.co/pyramid-principle-partone/) - lists Minto's three rules for building a pyramid, which govern grouping and summary rather than argument count.
- [Claude models overview (Anthropic docs)](https://platform.claude.com/docs/en/about-claude/models/overview) - confirms model ID `claude-opus-5-5`, a 1M-token context window, and a default effort of `medium`.
- [Introducing Claude Opus 5.5 (Anthropic)](https://www.anthropic.com/claude-opus-5-5) - confirms the 2026-09-22 release date and the low/medium/high/xhigh effort levels.
- [Understanding Claude's personalization features (Anthropic support)](https://support.claude.com/en/articles/10185728-understanding-claude-s-personalization-features) - names the account-wide setting "Instructions for Claude" and does not use the term "custom instructions."
- [Claude Cowork expands to mobile and web (TechCrunch, 2026-07-07)](https://techcrunch.com/2026/07/07/the-coding-agent-wars-are-spilling-into-the-rest-of-the-office-claude-cowork/) - confirms Cowork launched on desktop in January 2026 and that chat and Cowork are unified on web and desktop, matching the toggle in frames 017 and 018.
