---
title: "Are Web Designers Booked Solid Because AI Websites Backfired?"
date: "2026-11-09"
video_id: "7706289641414053133"
tiktok_url: "https://www.tiktok.com/@joshhaynam/video/7706289641414053133"
creator: "@joshhaynam"
category: "Business"
tags: ["web design", "ai websites", "uncanny valley", "web designer survey", "small business"]
excerpt: "Josh Haynam says AI websites backfired and web designers are fully booked. What a 500-designer survey shows, and why the uncanny valley claim is a metaphor."
---
Josh Haynam argues in a TikTok that AI-built websites backfired and that web designers are now fully booked. The claim rests on his own conversations with designers. The one large survey available, 20i's 2026 survey of 500 US web designers, shows a profession worried about AI and still fairly well paid, and it does not measure whether designers are booked.

## What the video claims

Haynam (@joshhaynam) opens with "why is every web designer I know fully booked until the end of the year?" and adds "I talk to web designers every day and they're fully, fully booked."

His explanation runs in four steps. Web design was one of the first things AI took over, because "Why would you pay thousands of dollars to have a custom website when Claude can just do it for you?" The use case grew quickly and earned AI companies "hundreds of millions of dollars." It then backfired, because AI sites fall into the uncanny valley and visitors leave. So businesses went back to human designers.

He closes with "AI is a great tool, but there's a lot of things that humans still have to do." The video shows only him speaking outdoors, with no data, examples or captions.

## Are web designers fully booked?

No source available here measures that. The best data is the 20i 2026 Web Designer Survey, published 16 March 2026. It polled 500 US web design professionals through Pollfish, with data correct as of February 2026, and it reports no booking or capacity figures.

Its nearest workload measure is time spent designing. 59% of designers spend 50 to 74% of their time on design, and 20.8% spend 75 to 100%. That describes how they divide their hours, not whether their calendars are full.

Haynam does not say how many designers he means or what kind of work they do. He posted on 9 November 2026, so "booked until the end of the year" covers about seven weeks, and he offers no comparison with earlier years. The claim is plausible for his circle and unproven for the market.

## Did AI take over web design?

The survey shows real pressure. 75% of designers say AI-driven competition has already affected them in the last year, and 76% name increasing AI use as their biggest concern about the industry's future. About 10% say AI chatbot referrals are their main source of new leads, so AI is also changing how work arrives.

The same survey reports that 36.6% of designers earn more than $100,000 a year and 78.6% feel properly compensated. That fits a market where simple sites move to AI tools while custom work stays with people. It does not show a takeover.

A TechRadar article's headline says 53% of small business owners are building websites themselves with AI. Only the headline loaded, so its source and sample are unknown. Nothing available ranks web design against other fields, so "one of the first things AI took over" is untested.

## Did AI website building earn "hundreds of millions"?

No source supports this figure. Haynam names no company, report or filing. Searches for revenue from website generation, including Anthropic's Economic Index, turned up general usage splits and a write-up noting that JavaScript and HTML are common in coding use. None gave a dollar figure for website building. AI companies generally report revenue by product line, not by what customers build with it.

## What is the uncanny valley, and does it apply to websites?

The uncanny valley was introduced by robotics professor Masahiro Mori in 1970, and the English term comes from Jasia Reichardt's 1978 book. It describes how people react to things that resemble humans. Comfort rises with human likeness, drops into revulsion when something is almost human, then recovers.

Haynam says "There's something called the uncanny valley where something looks kind of human but it's not and people hate it. Like they literally just leave." A website has no face or body, so applying the term to layout and copy is a metaphor. It may describe a real sense of artificiality, but Mori's idea does not predict it.

## Do visitors leave AI-built websites?

The video makes two claims here. Visitors leave AI-generated sites, and they lose trust in the business, reasoning "how do I know you're not using AI for your whole business?" No study comparing bounce rates or conversions on AI-built sites against designer-built sites was found. Industry surveys on trust in AI content exist, but they cover content and fake-site suspicion rather than visitor behavior on AI-built sites.

## Other reasons designers could be busy

Only the last step of Haynam's chain, that designers are busy, rests on observation, and it is anecdotal. Other explanations fit the same facts: fewer designers in the field, seasonal demand before year end, or clients who never tried AI tools at all. The 20i figures fit a split market as well as they fit a backlash.

## Bottom line

Haynam's claim that designers are booked solid comes from people he talks to, and no survey measures it. The 20i survey shows that 75% of designers feel AI competition and most still feel well paid. The revenue figure has no source, and the uncanny valley is a robotics idea used here as a metaphor.

## Sources

- [The 2026 Web Designer Survey, 20i, 16 March 2026](https://www.20i.com/blog/2026-web-designer-survey/): sample, AI concern figures, time on design and income.
- [Uncanny valley, Wikipedia](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Uncanny_valley): Mori's 1970 concept and Reichardt's 1978 English term.
- [TechRadar article on web coding gigs](https://techradar.com/pro/the-collapse-of-web-coding-gigs-is-getting-ugly-ai-takes-over-routine-website-development-jobs-and-business-owners-are-very-happy-with-its-job-so-far): headline on small business owners using AI for websites (body did not load).


## Video description and verification notes

**The clip runs 57.81 s (container) as a 720x1280 (9:16) MP4 (ISO base media, major brand isom) with an HEVC Main video stream at 30 fps (video duration 57.77 s, 1733 frames, 496,190 bps) and a stereo HE-AACv2 audio stream at 44.1 kHz (48,044 bps), for 550,682 bps overall and 3,979,373 bytes. metadata.json lists the format as bytevc1_720p_550673-1 and leaves fps null, so the 30 fps comes from ffprobe. It was posted at epoch 1794260408, which is 2026-11-09 21:40:08 UTC, by the handle @joshhaynam (uploader_id 7133975183917007915, nickname "Josh Haynam"). The audio credit is "original sound" by Josh Haynam. The description is one sentence of 11 words and repeats the title: "If AI is so great why are web designers fully booked?" The archive captured the metadata at 2026-11-10T13:01:15Z, about 15 hours after posting. At that point the video showed 308 views, 17 likes, 1 comment, 0 reposts and 2 saves. I read five frames from the 2-second set: frame_001 (about 0 s), frame_008 (about 14 s), frame_015 (about 28 s), frame_025 (about 48 s) and frame_029 (about 56 s). All five show the same shot: a man with short dark hair, clear-framed glasses and light stubble, wearing a lime-yellow zip jacket over a black T-shirt and a black ring. He holds a small black lavalier microphone with a fur windscreen near his chin and speaks to the camera. Behind him are a foggy white sky, a dark tree on the right and red roses at the lower left. No burned-in captions, lower-third cards, logos, URLs, screenshots, charts, website examples or screen recordings appear in any frame I read. I did not read the other frames, so I make no claim about them beyond the transcript, which covers the whole clip. The transcript has 13 segments (ids 0 to 12) and roughly 190 words. The argument is that web design was an early use case where people paid AI (he names Claude) to build sites instead of paying designers, that the use case grew fast and earned AI companies hundreds of millions of dollars, that it then "backfired" because AI sites trigger an uncanny-valley reaction and lose visitors' trust, and that designers he talks to are therefore booked through year end, which he reads as showing AI is a tool that still needs humans. The last transcript segment ends at 57.38 s, inside the 57.81 s audio stream, and the final words begin at 54.4 s, so the transcript is not hallucinated past the end of the audio. The one product name, Claude, matches the Anthropic product and was transcribed correctly.**

## The booked-designers claim is one person's anecdote, and the one survey I could read does not measure it

At 0.00 s the video says "why is every web designer I know fully booked until the end of the year?" and at 4.58 s adds "I talk to web designers every day and they're fully, fully booked." The evidence offered is personal contact with designers. No frame shows a waitlist, a survey, a job board or a booking tool, and the speaker does not say how many designers he means or what kind of work they do. He also does not say whether he talks to a mixed sample or to agencies and freelancers who sell to his own audience.

The best primary-style source I could read is the [20i 2026 Web Designer Survey](https://www.20i.com/blog/2026-web-designer-survey/), published 16 March 2026. It polled 500 US web design professionals through Pollfish, with data correct as of February 2026. The page does not report how many designers are booked or at capacity. Its nearest workload measure is the share of time spent designing: 59% spend 50 to 74% of their time on design and 20.8% spend 75 to 100%. That says how designers divide their hours, not whether their calendars are full. The same survey reports that 75% say AI-driven competition has already affected them in the last year and 76% name increasing AI use as their biggest concern about the industry's future. It also reports that 36.6% earn more than $100,000 a year and 78.6% feel properly compensated. Those figures show a profession that is worried about AI and still fairly well paid. They do not show a profession that is turning away work, and they do not contradict some designers being booked either.

Timing matters for reading "fully booked until the end of the year." The clip was posted on 9 November 2026, so the horizon is about seven weeks, and a short backlog at that point is common in any year. The video gives no comparison with earlier years, so it cannot say that bookings are higher than they would have been without AI. Verdict: unverified as a market-wide fact, plausible as a description of the speaker's circle.

## "Web design was one of the first things AI took over" has partial support, mostly at the low end

At 9.10 s the video says "Web design was one of the first things that AI took over," and at 13.56 s asks "Why would you pay thousands of dollars to have a custom website when Claude can just do it for you?" Search results point to real pressure on routine website work. A TechRadar report, whose headline says 53% of small business owners are building websites themselves with AI, appears in results alongside a figure of a 59% fall in web design and PHP job postings. I could not read that article's body: my fetch returned only the headline, so I cannot say who produced the 53% or 59% figures, their dates or their sample. I did not cite those numbers as established. A search summary of the article says it cautions that the data does not show an equal collapse across the whole industry, but I could not confirm that wording.

The 20i survey lends some support to the "took over" half of the claim, because three quarters of surveyed designers say AI competition has already affected them. It also reports that about 10% of respondents say AI chatbot referrals are their primary source of new leads, which shows AI changing how work arrives as well as who does it. The survey does not rank web design against other fields, so the "one of the first things" ordering is not tested by anything I read. Verdict: partly supported for simple sites, unverified as a ranking, and the speaker's own phrase "a lot of people did" is not backed with a count.

## "Hundreds of millions of dollars for the AI companies" has no source I could find

At 17.94 s the video says "a lot of people did and that use case grew extremely rapidly, generating hundreds of millions of dollars for the AI companies." The speaker names no company, report or filing. I searched for Anthropic's Economic Index and for revenue broken out by website generation. The results gave general usage splits, such as a share for computer and mathematical tasks in the first Economic Index report, and a secondary write-up saying web development languages like JavaScript and HTML are common in coding use. None gave a dollar figure for website building, and I could not open Anthropic's own pages to confirm the usage shares. Companies generally report revenue by product line, not by the type of site a customer builds, so a precise "website revenue" number would need a source the video does not give. Verdict: unverified. Without a source, the figure cannot be tied to Claude, other AI companies or website tools that use AI models.

## The "backfired" and uncanny-valley explanation borrows a term from robotics and has no direct test in what I read

At 30.00 s the video says "There's something called the uncanny valley where something looks kind of human but it's not and people hate it. Like they literally just leave." Per [Wikipedia's article on the uncanny valley](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Uncanny_valley), the concept was introduced by robotics professor Masahiro Mori in 1970, and the English term comes from Jasia Reichardt's 1978 book. It is a hypothesized relationship between how closely an object resembles a human and how people react to it: comfort rises with human likeness, drops into revulsion when something is almost human, then recovers. The article says nothing about websites or web design. A web page has no face or body to look "almost human," so applying the term to layout and copy is a metaphor. It may describe a real feeling of artificiality, but the original theory does not predict it.

The claim also contains two separate empirical assertions: that visitors leave AI-generated sites, and that they lose trust in the business behind them (the video's reasoning at 37.78 s: "how do I know you're not using AI for your whole business?"). My searches found industry surveys on trust in AI content, and a search summary mentions figures from vendors such as Kinsta, Pantheon and Capgemini. I did not open those pages, so I cannot confirm the numbers or their methods, and they concern content and fake-site suspicion, not whether AI-built sites lose visitors. I found no study that measures bounce rates or conversions on AI-built sites against designer-built sites. The summary also described a CHI study as finding that suspicion mattered more than whether text was actually AI-written, but I could not verify it. Verdict: the reaction is plausible but unmeasured in any source I read. The word "repulsive" and the phrase "they literally just leave" are opinion.

## The causal chain from "backfired" to "booked" skips other explanations

The video's chain has four steps: AI replaced designers, AI sites turned visitors away, businesses went back to designers, and designers filled up. Only the last step rests on observation, and it is anecdotal. The 20i data shows an equally consistent reading: designers feel competition from AI and are still earning well, which fits a market where low-end work moves to AI tools while custom work stays with people. A Reddit commenter quoted in my search results said much the same, but that is anecdote and I did not open the thread. Fewer designers, seasonal demand, or clients that never tried AI would also produce full calendars. The closing line at 50.88 s, "AI is a great tool, but there's a lot of things that humans still have to do," is an opinion that the sources I read neither prove nor refute.

## Key Takeaways

- **Unverified:** The video says at 0.00 s that "every web designer I know" is "fully booked until the end of the year." That rests on the speaker's own contacts. The 20i survey of 500 US designers does not report booking levels.
- **Partial correction:** At 9.10 s the video says AI "took over" web design. The 20i survey shows 75% of designers say AI-driven competition has already affected them, and a TechRadar headline reports 53% of small business owners using AI for their websites, but I could not read that article's method. The evidence I have covers pressure on routine sites, not a takeover or a ranking against other fields.
- **Unverified:** At 17.94 s the video says AI companies earned "hundreds of millions of dollars" from this use case. I found no source that breaks out website-building revenue.
- **Clarification:** The uncanny valley, as described by Mori in 1970, concerns resemblance to humans. Using it for websites is a figure of speech, and the claims that visitors leave and lose trust were not tested in any source I opened.
- **Context:** The video shows one man speaking outdoors with a lavalier microphone. It shows no data, no websites and no captions, and it had 308 views at capture, so the claims are an informal opinion and not a report.

## Resources

- [The 2026 Web Designer Survey, 20i, 16 March 2026](https://www.20i.com/blog/2026-web-designer-survey/) establishes the sample (500 US designers via Pollfish, data as of February 2026), the 75% affected by AI competition, the 76% concerned about AI, the time-on-design and income figures, and that the page reports no booking-level data.
- [Uncanny valley, Wikipedia](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Uncanny_valley) establishes that Mori introduced the concept in 1970, that the English term dates to Reichardt's 1978 book, and that the concept concerns human likeness and does not mention websites. I read only the first 100,000 of about 189,000 characters.
- [TechRadar article on web coding gigs](https://techradar.com/pro/the-collapse-of-web-coding-gigs-is-getting-ugly-ai-takes-over-routine-website-development-jobs-and-business-owners-are-very-happy-with-its-job-so-far) established only its headline (53% of small business owners using AI for website creation) when I fetched it. The body did not load, so I rely on it for nothing beyond that headline.
- Source note: TikTok pages were not fetched because the site disallows Claude's agents. The video's content comes from the staged artifact (metadata, transcript, ffprobe output and the five frames above).
