---
title: "A Performance Review Framework: Five Statements and Two Questions"
date: "2026-05-26"
video_id: "7340370998681734443"
tiktok_url: "https://www.tiktok.com/@graceforpersonalityhires/video/7340370998681734443"
creator: "@graceforpersonalityhires"
category: "Business"
tags: ["performance review", "employee motivation", "management", "one on one meetings", "career development"]
excerpt: "Grace's performance review framework replaces ratings with five manager statements and two questions about team direction, skills and a character arc."
---
> [TikTok by @graceforpersonalityhires](https://www.tiktok.com/@graceforpersonalityhires/video/7340370998681734443), 105 seconds

Grace opens with a story about a client call: a company had just finished performance reviews and the result was chaos. Nobody was motivated. Everyone was unhappy. (She then admits this was actually a dream, but she built the framework anyway.) Her argument: standard performance reviews that tell someone they "meet expectations" do nothing useful. She proposes a replacement structure built around five statements and two questions that a manager delivers directly to the employee.

## The Framework: Five Statements and Two Questions

### Five Statements

1. **Here is the team's bigger picture for the rest of the year.** Set the context. The employee needs to understand where the team is headed before they can understand their own role in it.

2. **Here is how you fit into the team's bigger picture.** Connect the individual to that direction. This is the step most reviews skip entirely: telling someone where they stand without telling them where the team is going.

3. **Here are the three most useful skills you are bringing to the table right now.** Name three specific strengths. This grounds the review in what the person is already doing well, with enough specificity that it feels real.

4. **Here are the three skills we could really use you sharpening up on.** Name three specific growth areas. Paired with the strengths, this reads as investment rather than criticism.

5. **Here is the character arc I think could be really powerful for you.** This is the most unusual piece. The manager describes a trajectory: "I see you moving from this type of role with these skill sets to this type of role with these skill sets." It frames development as a narrative the employee can see themselves in, not a checklist of deficiencies.

### Two Questions

1. **As your manager, what kind of guidance do you need from me?** Puts the manager in a support role rather than a judging role.

2. **What character arc do you find to be the most motivating? What are you looking for here?** Gives the employee agency over their own development story. Their answer might differ from the manager's version, and that gap is where the real conversation happens.

## Key Takeaways

- Traditional performance reviews that rate people on a scale produce anxiety, not motivation. The format itself is the problem.
- Motivation comes from context (where is the team going), connection (how do I fit), recognition (what I do well), and trajectory (where I could go).
- The "character arc" concept reframes growth as a story rather than a gap analysis. People respond to narratives about their future more than they respond to ratings of their past.
- Ending with questions instead of directives turns the review into a two-way conversation. The employee leaves with ownership over what happens next.
